Comments on: 13. Stocking https://tankstartguide.com Based on Science and Logic Wed, 11 Mar 2026 14:32:12 +0000 hourly 1 By: CodyG https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-3517 Wed, 11 Mar 2026 14:32:12 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-3517 Hi Dave. So I have a few questions. Your stocking chart above for a 100 gallon that lists light, max recommended and heavy, is that based on the 100ft2 amount of media for 1lb of fish? I have a submerged static foam sump that has roughly 3,000 cu inches of 20/30ppi foam so if I follow your formula of 500 cu inches of media for 100ft2 per pound of fish that would be roughly 6lbs of fish I could keep and crystal clear water would be achieved. How does that then tie in to the stocking chart for the 100 gallon? Would that allow me to keep more than the heavy stocking or am I missing something and need to read more on the stocking ratios article?

]]>
By: Hop https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2027 Wed, 08 Oct 2025 02:53:35 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2027 It perfectly captures my thoughts when I read this article. Many aquarium articles from Europe and the U.S. tend to present fixed numbers for fish stocking, and anyone who keeps fish at a higher density is often criticized. In Asia—especially Southeast Asia—we have a different approach. We usually don’t use sponge filters or canister filters; we use sumps that are as large as the main tanks. The water pumps have a very high turnover rate, and when using moving bed media (e.g., K1), we employ strong air pumps.

I’ve seen tanks around 160 liters (about 40 gallons) that house more than 30 large ranchu and oranda goldfish. The water remains crystal clear, odorless, and the fish are healthy. When it comes to koi, filtration systems in Asia are often half the size of the pond itself, and some even build filter chambers equal to two-thirds of the pond’s volume. That’s why seeing large koi crowded together in clean, clear water is quite common here.

Even with discus fish—known for being extremely sensitive to water quality—Southeast Asian breeders are masters at developing new, colorful strains. Our discus tanks are stocked very densely, yet the fish stay strong and healthy. Therefore, stocking density primarily depends on the filtration system. What may seem overcrowded and risky for one person could be perfectly fine for another. It doesn’t mean that the latter doesn’t care for their fish or doesn’t know what they’re doing.

]]>
By: alam fathoni https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2026 Sun, 01 Jun 2025 10:07:45 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2026 saya punya ikan arwana saya pindah ke akuarium baru lantas menabrak2 kaca dan berhenti makan saya pindah lagi ke akuarium lama dgn tambahan red bludog obat dan ikan mau makan lagi dan tak pindah lagi le akuarium baru dgn cara memasukan ke plastik di angkat dan di tuang ke akuarium baru..ikan menabrak nabrak dinding dan brenti makan lagi
air di akuarium baru sdh cycle mature

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2025 Fri, 02 May 2025 08:25:39 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2025 In reply to Mikhail E.

Things won’t be too crowded. That assumes you have adequate filtration and aeration.

]]>
By: Mikhail E https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2024 Wed, 30 Apr 2025 20:38:56 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2024 I have the following in a 45 gallon tank:
2 Electric Blue Acara
2 Geophagus Sveni
4 Glow Tetra
8 Serpae Tetra
1 Rubber Nose Pleco

I would like to add one grown Sevrum.
Is that going to be too crowded?

My parameters are stable.

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2023 Tue, 25 Mar 2025 00:42:01 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2023 In reply to Jaume.

You are hunting for nano fish. Good choices include schools of six or more: Daisy’s blue ricefish, white cloud mountain minnows, otocinclus, pygmy corydoras, Celestichthys margaritatus (“celestial pearl danio” or “galaxy rasbora”), glowlight tetra, dwarf pencilfish, various small danios, small barbs such as ruby, and cherry, and small rasboras such as emerald, dwarf, lampeye, chili, phoenix, somphong, galaxy and pygmy. A school of green kubotai rasbora is stunning! Note ALL these fish get aggressive if not in schools of at least six fish

Look up the adult size of the fish. Some experienced nano fish enthusiasts recommend sticking with fish under one inch as adults. The list of fish which get larger than one inch includes such fish as the harlequin rasbora (2 inch), pork chop rasbora (2 inch), golden barbs (4 inches), Odessa barbs (3 inch), checkerboard barbs (2 inch), most corydoras (3 inch), black phantom tetras (2 inch), lemon tetra (2 inch), bleeding heart tetra (3 inch), tiger barbs (3 inch), and most of the glofish (the danios are fine). Hobbyists will be surprised how big these fish get. They MAY be cramped in small tanks. But this is an OPINION, not a scientific fact. So if you want a school of harlequin rasboras in a ten gallon, go for it!

Other good fish which do not need to be in schools are Endler livebearer, scarlet badis (Dario Dario), dwarf chain loaches, peacock gudgeon, sparkling gourami, Tanganyikan shellies, and the betta. My personal favorites are the Tanganyikan shellies (Lamprologus ocellatus and their relatives). They are tiny cichlids with great personalities. Just be sure to include some two inch snail shells which the “shellies” use for homes.

Bettas are good but generally need to be alone in a small tank (sometimes they tolerate tankmates and sometimes they do not). Avoid blackwater fish like neons, cardinals, rummy nose tetras and rams. These are NOT starter fish. Same goes for dwarf frogs and shrimp. Read this article for more information. http://tankstartguide.com/index.php/17-9-nano-aquarium/

]]>
By: Jaume https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2022 Sat, 22 Mar 2025 23:44:06 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2022 I have a recently started walstad-like aquarium (mentioned in comments in another page), +-15l, organic-like soil capped with gravel, with anubias, crypto, bacota and sagittaria that are still establishing (some melting, some rotting), also duckweed and many snails that appeared spontaneously along very tiny detritus (?) worms populating the aquarium walls. I do not have any artificial light, but the aquarium is in front of a glass door with a lot of indirect light most of the day. Filtration is done only by a small backpack filter with foam (not on the intake). Water is starting to look better, still not clear, and yellowish, but I assume that is normal for Walstad. Water temp is around 24 with the heater, in summer the water may get up to 30º, perhaps 27º if I can use a fan (although unsure how to deal with floating plants and a fan). I haven’t tested the water at all for parameters.

I want to add some fish, either soon or after the aquarium can be considered cycled, I don’t mind. What would your recommendations be? I prefer small fish, as it is a small aquarium, and that would allow me to have more of them; I am also a beginner, so easy fish are preferred. Thank you very much for your help

]]>
By: M https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2021 Sat, 15 Feb 2025 08:28:10 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2021 In reply to dave, thanks for taking the time to help me out.

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2020 Fri, 14 Feb 2025 23:10:08 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2020 In reply to M.

In reply to M …. Yes the black ones. Stuff the HOB with as many of those inserts as will fit. And you can replace kuhli’s with Cories.

]]>
By: M https://tankstartguide.com/13-stocking/#comment-2019 Fri, 14 Feb 2025 11:08:31 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2058#comment-2019 In reply to dave, do you mean the black ones, if so i already have one in the filter. i also would like to know if i can replace the kuhli loaches with 5 cories to get 8 cories in total and some caridinia shrimp instead as i reand the corys need to be in a large shoal.

]]>