Comments on: 12.5. Fish Don’t Drink https://tankstartguide.com Based on Science and Logic Wed, 25 Dec 2024 13:40:20 +0000 hourly 1 By: Erik https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1969 Wed, 25 Dec 2024 13:40:20 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1969 Please provide evidence for this claim: “Studies show fish put in a shallow bath of medication can swallow some medication”

]]>
By: Chelle https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1968 Fri, 13 Sep 2024 06:55:56 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1968 Hi,
Just wondered if you have anything on columnaris? I suspect it’s in my tank.
I’m in the UK so a lot of recommended medications just aren’t available here.
Your information is fascinating and a newbie like me is learning a lot, if a little overwhelmed at times.

Also, I love all the photos featured throughout your website, so many fish I’ve never even seen before!
Thankyou for you hard work and perseverance in maintaining a website like this.

]]>
By: Suzanne https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1967 Tue, 13 Aug 2024 14:51:22 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1967 Enjoying this site! The bit about freshwater fish not drinking puzzled me until I recalled it’s actually saltwater fish that are constantly drinking…

Purely anecdotal, but decades ago our family aquarium goldfish suffered fin rot. We dosed them with many teracycline capsules, but they never improved. When I had my own tank (goldfish again, ofcourse!) and fin rot showed up, I used Tetramin “medicated food” (tetracycline I believe) and it worked so well I always kept some around “just in case.” It is a shame, I haven’t seen that product for sale in years.

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1966 Fri, 26 Jan 2024 22:28:18 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1966 In reply to Doreen A Simonson.

In reply to Doreen… Hole in the head wont’ have frayed fins. The two biggest causes of frayed fins is a bacterial infection (hemorrhagic septicemia is bacterial) and aggression. Assuming it was bacterial and you’ve stopped the bacteria, it will take months for the fins to regrow.

]]>
By: Doreen A Simonson https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1965 Fri, 26 Jan 2024 20:23:28 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1965 Thanks Dave for your quick response. My sister has asked so many different people what was wrong with her fish and everyone always has a different answer and a different treatment. Would hole in the head cause frayed fins? There has never been any sign of fin rot or a fungus attacking the fins. Through the help of your website I determined it was hemorrhagic septicemia and by examining the fish. She had purchased a true parrot fish from a local pet store and they determined that he had hole in the head but the “sickness” was already in the tank. My very last question what disease would cause ragged fins? We have been dealing with this for so long.

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1964 Fri, 26 Jan 2024 06:32:36 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1964 In reply to Doreen A Simonson.

In reply to Doreen …. The frayed fins will regrow. Just give them some time. Vitamins are worthless.

]]>
By: Doreen A Simonson https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1963 Fri, 26 Jan 2024 04:01:52 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1963 Hello Dave
I am hoping you can answer a question for me. My sister has 2 Angelfish that have raggedy
dorsal and anal fins. She previously had a few fish in her tank that we believe had hemorrhagic septicemia. She added Maracyn and Aqua-Mox anti-biotics to their food, and continued with that for 18 days. She also purchased a UV light to help remove bacteria from the water. What we would like to know is will the “frayed” fins ever regrow? I have read on line that you can give fish vitamin c (fish vitamins) and that will help rejuvenate the fins. Is this true?
Do you have any suggestions for us? Please answer me.

]]>
By: Patrick McArdle https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1962 Thu, 25 Jan 2024 05:21:47 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1962 I have injected Clout mixed with tank water directly past the gills and into the Cichlids stomach that had bloat with 85% success rate. All 7 fish hadn’t eaten in 2-3 weeks and were in their last legs ( fins lol). I saved 5. Within two days they were eating. This is the inly way. Meds don’t like sticking to food and i din’t believe in that focus..lol. scams. Inject the meds into belly. Case closed.

]]>
By: Dave https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1961 Wed, 29 Nov 2023 08:42:57 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1961 In reply to David.

In reply to David …. Antibiotics in the water is 100% useless. It will have no effect on anything. So no, a two pronged approach will not be better. It will only waste antibiotic.

]]>
By: David https://tankstartguide.com/12-5-fish-dont-drink/#comment-1960 Wed, 29 Nov 2023 01:02:59 +0000 http://tankstartguide.com/?page_id=2014#comment-1960 Hi,

Would it make a significant difference if one uses antibiotics in the food in addition to adding antibiotics in the water? Do you think this two-pronged approach would lead to a quicker recovery?

Thank you,
David

]]>